do it for the plot

3 min read 23-01-2025

"Do it for the plot" has become a popular meme and internet adage, often used humorously to justify wildly improbable or morally questionable actions in fiction. But there's a deeper truth behind the seemingly flippant phrase. Sometimes, a compelling narrative necessitates choices that might otherwise seem illogical or even reprehensible. This article explores the significance of prioritizing plot in storytelling, examining when and why sacrificing realism or character consistency can serve the story's greater good.

Understanding the "Do It for the Plot" Phenomenon

The phrase itself highlights a fundamental tension in storytelling: the balance between realistic character portrayal and the demands of a gripping plot. Characters might act "out of character" or events unfold in ways that defy probability. However, this is not necessarily a sign of poor writing. Instead, it can be a deliberate artistic choice to advance the narrative and deliver a satisfying conclusion.

When "Out-of-Character" Actions are Justified

High Stakes: If the stakes are incredibly high—the fate of the world, a loved one's life—characters might behave in ways they wouldn't normally. The pressure of the situation can lead to desperate measures.
Character Development: A seemingly irrational action can reveal hidden depths or unexpected facets of a character. It can challenge our assumptions and lead to a more nuanced understanding of their motivations.
Plot Twists: Sometimes, a seemingly unbelievable event is necessary to create a shocking twist or a surprising turn of events. The unexpected nature of the action can heighten the emotional impact and keep the audience engaged.
Narrative Necessity: Occasionally, a specific action might be required to move the plot forward in a meaningful way. This might involve a character making a sacrifice, revealing a secret, or embarking on a seemingly foolhardy quest.

The Ethical Considerations: Justifying Moral Ambiguity

Using the "do it for the plot" justification doesn't give writers a free pass to create morally reprehensible characters or events without consequences. It's crucial to carefully consider the ethical implications of such choices and to ensure that these actions are handled with sensitivity and nuance.

Balancing Plot and Morality

Consequences: Even if a character acts "out of character" for the plot, there should be consequences for their actions. This adds realism and prevents the story from feeling contrived.
Exploration of Themes: Moral ambiguity can provide an opportunity to explore complex ethical dilemmas and challenge the audience to confront difficult questions.
Character Arcs: Characters who make morally questionable choices should ideally experience a transformation or growth throughout the story. This demonstrates internal conflict and a complex moral journey.

Examples of "Do It for the Plot" in Action

Numerous examples in popular fiction demonstrate the effective use of this storytelling principle. In many mystery novels, the detective might make a risky decision, even if it appears illogical, to catch the killer. The thrill comes from seeing how this seemingly rash act impacts the plot. Similarly, in fantasy and science fiction, characters might sacrifice their own happiness or safety to save the world.

Case Studies: Analyzing Successful Examples

Analyzing successful examples reveals that the "do it for the plot" approach should never be arbitrary. There must be a clear reason for the character's unconventional action, and that action should ultimately serve a larger narrative purpose. It is a tool to be used skillfully, not carelessly.

Conclusion: A Balancing Act

While the phrase "do it for the plot" may sound flippant, it speaks to a fundamental truth about storytelling: sometimes, the needs of the narrative must take precedence over strict adherence to realism or character consistency. However, writers must employ this principle judiciously. The key is to find the right balance between a compelling plot and believable characters, ensuring that any out-of-character actions or improbable events serve a purpose within the larger narrative and are handled with sensitivity and skill. It's about knowing when to break the rules—and why. The plot should drive the story, but it shouldn't come at the cost of a completely hollow or unbelievable narrative.